West Marine finally called to let me know that the new stove is at the store and waiting to be picked up. Yay!
After much reading and much contemplation, we ended up buying the Force 10 three-burner stove. It’s the same stove that we had in our previous sailboat, so we figured since that one had lasted over 30 years, it would be a good choice. Now to install it without throwing out by back again!